For one of my directories I use Site-Sift Listings. It’s a free directory script that you can find here. They also offer a paid version that has no real differences from the free script other than it gives you permission to remove the Powered by Site-Sift from your pages. Personally I have paid to remove it for various reasons that I will probably discuss in a future post.
Let’s start from the basics, Site-sift was very easy to install and configure. It looks pretty nice out of the box and just by adding a nice logo you can have a Botw.org style directory. It provides SE friendly URLs that can be crawled easily from the search engine bots and all the listings are search engine friendly. Finally it is quite easy for users
to submit their links, a fact that is very important if you want to get a lot of submissions.
Now let’s go to the negatives.
My biggest gripes with this directory script is that the admin panel is not really user friendly. Some examples:
The awaiting validation page isn’t paginated, so you may ask what is wrong with that? Wait until you get a few hundreds or thousands submissions awaiting validation and then you will see why this is a big problem. Everytime you approve or delete a submission the page reloads and if you have that may listings it becomes time consuming. Recently that I had this problem I decided to do the reviewing from PHPMyAdmin, no I am not kidding.
Another thing that is missing is the mass approve or delete buttons, something like the wordpress comments moderating system would be ideal.
Adding categories or moving them wasn’t thought out very well in my opinion as well. Why? because the categories tree doesn’t allow you to identify parent and child categories easily.
Overall it’s a good script, however I would like a bit more user friendly admin panel *hint hint*
Related Posts
- Free Directory Scripts Name: Site-Sift Listing Language: PHP Paid Version: Yes (59.95$) Name: PHP Link Directory Language: PHP Paid Version: Yes (25$ with footer link 75$ without footer
- dirSpace Web Directory Review This is the first of a series of Directory reviews (mainly paid) that I am planning on writting mainly because
- Koopy Review This is my first review of a niche web directy and what better place to start than a directory of
- Human Ranked Directory Project Review Today I am going to do a mini review of Human Ranked Directory Project. The main characteristic of this relatively
July 1st, 2006 at 2:30 am
Hi,
Nice review of the script. I agree with you on several point in the admin section of the script. At the moment we are writing some mods for the script, like the email template mod. see here http://forum.site-sift.com/thread978.html
You’re running a nice webdirectory with webmasterhole. Stick around at the site-sift forums and post your mod request, maby we’ll find somebody to programm a mod for the awaiting validation page.
Thanks,